Can Criminal Intent Be Proven By Expert Opinion?

What is the difference between “possession” of drugs and “possession with intent to deliver” drugs?  In Nebraska, it’s having one ounce of cocaine and “expert testimony” that one ounce is too much for personal use. Expert opinion of possession with intent to deliver can make a difference in punishment. Mere possession of cocaine in Nebraska is a Class IV felony, punishable by up to two years in prison and a $10,000 fine.  Possession with intent to deliver carries a minimum penalty of three years imprisonment.

On April 1, 2022, the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed the conviction of a western Nebraska attorney of one count of possession of a controlled substance, cocaine, with intent to distribute. Defendant was the Box Butte County Public Defender at the time of the offense, January 7, 2020. The court sentenced Defendant to the mandatory minimum sentence of three years imprisonment.

There was no evidence he had ever delivered or attempted to deliver a controlled substance to anyone in Scotts Bluff or anywhere else, according to his defense attorney at the time of sentencing. (Alliance Times-Herald, March 31, 2021).   However, the charge of “possession with intent” does not require proof of delivery, but simply proof of intent. In this case proof of intent was largely based on circumstantial evidence including “expert testimony” by a Scotts Bluff police department investigator.

The Nebraska Supreme Court made it clear that “evidence of the quantity of a controlled substance possessed, combined with expert testimony that such quantity indicates an intent to deliver, can be sufficient for a jury to infer an intent to deliver.” State vs. Worthman, 311 Neb. 284, at 291 (2022). The lesson for potential defendants is this:  There need not be proof that any amount of cocaine (and many other drugs) was ever distributed, delivered or sold. Circumstantial evidence that “a lot of cocaine” was possessed, “expert testimony” that such amount was more than enough for one user, can convict a defendant of possession with intent to deliver.